The Most Underrated Theatre Songs That Deserve More Spotlight

Let’s face it: theatre fans love a big showstopper. “Defying Gravity,” “One Day More,” and “Waving Through a Window” are practically part of the Broadway national anthem by now. But what about the songs that never got their flowers? The hidden gems tucked into Act Two, or buried on an underappreciated cast album?

Whether they were overshadowed by a show’s bigger numbers or just came from productions that didn’t quite hit mainstream fame, here are some of the most underrated theatre songs that deserve a standing ovation of their own.

1. "Flying Away" – Fun Home (London version)

While “Ring of Keys” rightfully made waves, the London version of Fun Home added “Flying Away,” a soft, soaring song sung by Small Alison that captures the ache and hope of childhood. It’s simple, heartfelt, and honestly, criminally overlooked.

2. "Pretty Funny" – Dogfight

This ballad, sung by Rose after a night gone wrong, is raw vulnerability wrapped in melody. Lindsay Mendez crushed it in the original Off-Broadway run, and yet the song rarely gets the attention it deserves. It’s a gut-punch—quiet, bruised, and beautiful.

3. "I Can Do Better Than That" – The Last Five Years

Okay, hear us out: The Last Five Years is far from obscure, but “I Can Do Better Than That” often takes a back seat to “Still Hurting” or “If I Didn’t Believe in You.” This one is a masterclass in storytelling—full of dreams, momentum, and character.

4. "Heart and Music" – A New Brain

William Finn’s A New Brain is a cult favorite, but “Heart and Music” deserves way more love. It’s a celebration of life, creativity, and connection—one of those songs that makes you want to run outside and hug the world. Or at least your castmates.

5. "Some Things Are Meant to Be" – Little Women

Tucked into a show that’s often dismissed as “nice but forgettable,” this duet between Jo and Beth is emotionally devastating. It’s a gentle goodbye that hits like a wave, and for anyone who’s lost someone close, it cuts deep.

6. "When I Look at You" – The Scarlet Pimpernel

This show is full of dramatic flair, but this particular ballad is a sweeping, romantic knockout. It’s classic Broadway with heart-on-your-sleeve energy, and its emotional punch shouldn’t be underestimated.

7. "Spread a Little Sunshine" – Pippin

Buried in the razzle-dazzle of Pippin’s ensemble numbers is this campy, sly solo by Fastrada. It’s got groove, sass, and a deliciously manipulative tone that’s often overlooked. Bonus points for being a brilliant audition cut.

8. "What Would You Do?" – Cabaret

“Cabaret” the title track might steal the show, but this haunting ballad from Fraulein Schneider is a standout in its own right. It’s a sobering reflection on compromise, survival, and quiet despair—and it lands like a gut punch when done right.

9. "Before It’s Over" – Dogfight

Yes, Dogfight gets two mentions—because it’s that underrated. “Before It’s Over” is an anthem for anyone who’s ever struggled to find their voice. Soaring and emotional, it ends the show with power and grace.

10. "Let It Sing" – Violet

If you’ve never listened to Violet, stop reading and go listen to the original cast recording (or the Sutton Foster revival). “Let It Sing” is a gospel-tinged powerhouse, and if it doesn’t stir something in your soul… are you sure you’re alive?

Honourable Mentions:

“Quasimodo” – Notre Dame de Paris

“Come to Your Senses” – tick, tick… BOOM!

“Say the Word” – The Unauthorized Autobiography of Samantha Brown

“The Schmuel Song” – The Last Five Years

“Mama Who Bore Me (Reprise)” – Spring Awakening

Final Thoughts

There’s nothing wrong with loving the big hits—but the real magic of theatre lives in the lesser-known moments, too. These songs may not always make the playlist, but they stay with you long after the curtain falls.

Got a favourite underrated song we missed? Drop it in the comments or tag us on socials—we’re always up for discovering a new hidden gem!